The beauty industry is crowded with established players and emerging brands all vying for consumer attention. Yet, e.l.f. Beauty has managed to consistently stand out, positioning itself as a disruptor by combining bold marketing campaigns with innovative strategies. In this case study, we will explore some of e.l.f.’s most recent creative initiatives and break down the key tactics behind their success.
What You Will Learn
- How e.l.f. Beauty leverages unique partnerships to amplify brand awareness
- The role of digital platforms and viral content in capturing consumer attention
- How e.l.f. used data to drive a strategic campaign decision
- Why product innovation and bold messaging can strengthen brand loyalty
- Actionable strategies to foster community engagement through creative campaigns
Leveraging Unique Partnerships to Amplify Brand Awareness
e.l.f. Beauty has taken a fresh approach to partnerships, one of the most notable being their recent collaboration with Tinder. The “e.l.f. x Tinder Put Yourself Out There Vault” campaign seamlessly blended beauty and dating culture to engage a broader audience. By partnering with Tinder, e.l.f. cleverly tapped into a millennial and Gen Z demographic, reinforcing their relevance among younger consumers.
What You Can Learn:
- Think outside traditional industry collaborations: Retail brands often look within their sector for partnerships. Consider looking at platforms outside your industry where your target audience spends time. For example, e.l.f.’s collab with Chipotle for a burrito bowl-inspired eyeshadow palette.
- Create cultural moments: e.l.f. didn’t just release a new product—they created a social moment by tying beauty to self-expression and dating, making their campaign more relatable.
The Power of Viral and Digital-First Content
e.l.f. Beauty is no stranger to digital marketing, as seen in their recent earnings release. A large part of their success has come from their embrace of social media, viral trends and influencer partnerships. For example, their viral #eyeslipsface campaign on TikTok garnered billions of views, showcasing the effectiveness of digital-first strategies.
What You Can Learn:
- Go where your audience is most active: TikTok and Instagram have become the go-to platforms for e.l.f.’s audience, and the brand has expertly used short-form content to drive engagement. Retailers can similarly benefit by adapting their content strategy to where their audience spends the most time.
- Leverage UGC content: Encouraging consumers to participate in trends can turn customers into brand advocates. For example, creating fun challenges or influencer collaborations can increase organic engagement.
Using Data to Drive Campaign Decisions
A key element of e.l.f.’s success lies in their use of data to inform creative decisions. In the e.l.f. x Tinder campaign, research revealed that people with red lips get more swipes on Tinder. Leveraging this data, e.l.f. launched the “Put Yourself Out There Vault,” which included their red lip products, perfectly timed with the insight that red lips boost engagement on the dating app.
As highlighted by the Dieline, e.l.f. used this data to create a campaign that aligned with consumer behavior on Tinder. By integrating such insights, they ensured the campaign was not only creative but also backed by relevant consumer preferences, resulting in more targeted marketing efforts.
What You Can Learn:
- Expand your data collection: Data-driven insights can give you an edge in creating campaigns that resonate with your target audience. Go beyond the surface-level metrics and dig into how your customers are behaving across platforms, then craft marketing messages that speak directly to those behaviors.
- Use data to personalize your campaigns: Knowing what captures attention in specific contexts can help you design more effective marketing strategies. Whether it’s social media trends, purchase behaviors, or platform-specific actions, data allows you to innovate based on facts.
Bold Messaging and Product Innovation Strengthen Brand Loyalty
e.l.f. has also used its messaging to stand out from competitors. The brand embraces bold and unapologetic campaigns, which tie personal expression with beauty empowerment. Beyond clever messaging, e.l.f. has introduced innovative products, often at affordable price points, making high-quality beauty more accessible.
What You Can Learn:
- Boldly differentiate your brand voice: In a crowded market, being daring can help your brand stand out. Whether through cheeky product names or socially relevant messaging, don’t be afraid to break from tradition.
- Make innovation accessible: e.l.f. consistently shows that innovation doesn’t have to come at a premium. By offering exciting, affordable products, they maintain loyalty while attracting new customers.
Fostering Community Engagement through Creativity
One of the hallmarks of e.l.f. Beauty is their ability to create a sense of community. Their campaigns often feel personal, fun and interactive, fostering a deeper connection with their audience. Their ability to turn ordinary marketing into a community-building tool allows them to engage audiences on a more personal level. Check out their CommerceNexty Award-winning example here.
What You Can Learn:
- Create shared experiences: Just like e.l.f. tying their campaigns to personal expression and self-confidence, think about how your brand can invite customers to feel part of a larger community.
- Engage creatively with your audience: Don’t just market to consumers—invite them into the conversation. Whether through social media campaigns or interactive content, give them a reason to feel connected to your brand.
e.l.f. Beauty has proven that with bold ideas, innovative product development and a keen understanding of their audience, a brand can rise above the noise of a competitive industry. By taking inspiration from their campaigns, retail brands can tap into cultural relevance, strengthen community engagement and stand out in their own ways.
For ecommerce, marketing and technology leaders looking to adopt these strategies, the key takeaway is to stay agile, prioritize creativity and embrace data-driven insights to better understand consumer behavior. As e.l.f. Beauty continues to disrupt the beauty world, they offer a playbook that can be applied across industries.
If you want to learn more transformative insights like these, sign up now to get early access to 150+ industry-leading speakers at the 2025 CommerceNext Growth Show!
